Pin it
Nothing beats biting into a hot, homemade bagel when your morning's crazy busy. These protein-packed cottage cheese bagels have become my go-to breakfast, discovered by chance when I couldn't find yogurt one day. I've played with the recipe for years and now have a quick, protein-loaded version that works with practically anything. My grandkids go nuts for them cut into tiny "bagel chunks," and my hubby swears they're better than what he gets at his favorite deli in New York. You can make them in your oven or air fryer and they're done in less than 30 minutes—no waiting for yeast, no hassle, just pure yummy goodness.
The first time I brought these to our family get-together, my niece who normally avoids bread asked for more—three times! The cottage cheese gives them a nice little zing and keeps them soft inside, while you can top them however you want.
Essential Components
- All-purpose flour: Your main building block. Sometimes I swap half for whole wheat to add some earthiness.
- Baking powder: Must be fresh! Just toss a bit in warm water—bubbles mean it's good to go.
- Kosher salt: Brings out flavor without being too much. Cut amount in half if you're using regular table salt.
- Cottage cheese: Get the full-fat kind and drain it well. I like Good Culture brand since it's thicker and won't make your dough wet.
- Egg wash: Makes them shiny. If you can't do eggs, brush with some olive oil and press your toppings in.
- Toppings: Everything bagel mix is what I reach for most, but try dried herbs or sunflower seeds too.
Making Your Bagels
- Combine dry stuff
- Grab a big bowl and mix 1 ½ cups flour, 1 tablespoon baking powder, and 1 teaspoon kosher salt. Make sure there aren't any lumps so your bagels rise evenly.
- Get the cottage cheese ready
- Take 1 cup cottage cheese and push it through a strainer over the sink. Let it sit 3-4 minutes until it's more like crumbs. Skip this part and you'll end up with dough stuck all over your hands.
- Mix and work the dough
- Dump your drained cottage cheese into the flour mix. Mash it with a fork until it looks like wet sand, then hand-knead for about 2 minutes. It should feel slightly sticky but not gooey—add a bit more flour if needed.
- Form your bagels
- Cut the dough into 4 equal chunks. Roll each piece into a rope about ¾-inch thick, then connect the ends to make a circle. Wet your fingers to smooth out any cracks.
- Put on toppings
- Brush beaten egg over each bagel and cover with your favorite toppings. Want extra crunch? Push seeds into the sides too.
- Cook them up
- Air fryer way: Set to 280°F and cook 15 minutes till golden. Oven way: Bake at 375°F on the upper rack for 25 minutes. Let them cool 15 minutes—cutting too early flattens them.
Pin it
I've come to love the subtle richness from the cottage cheese. My husband, who used to only eat traditional bagels, now asks for these every week, especially when they're toasted crispy and topped with smoked salmon.
Keeping & Enjoying
These taste best right out of the oven, but they save well too. Wrap cooled bagels in foil and keep in the fridge up to 5 days. For a fast morning meal, cut one open, toast it golden, and add avocado with a dash of chili flakes. If you're planning ahead, slice them before freezing; they'll thaw quickly and stay chewy.
Different Diet Options
Need gluten-free? Try swapping in Cup4Cup flour blend instead. Going vegan? Skip the egg wash and use aquafaba or olive oil to stick your toppings. I've tried making them with almond flour for fewer carbs, but they turn out heavier—great for open-face sandwiches though.
These cottage cheese protein bagels aren't just another recipe—they're my secret weapon for crazy mornings and proof that basic ingredients can make something amazing. After baking for more years than I care to count, I really value food that's both simple and nutritious, and these hit both marks. Give them a shot, and I bet they'll become your new breakfast favorite.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I swap regular flour for gluten-free?
- Absolutely, a gluten-free blend like cup4cup works perfectly fine.
- → What's the best way to keep these bagels fresh?
- Pop them in the freezer wrapped in plastic or foil. Heat them up in the oven when you're ready to eat.
- → Do I need an air fryer to make these?
- Not at all, just bake them in your oven at 375°F for about 25 minutes.
- → Is there anything I can use instead of cottage cheese?
- The cottage cheese gives these their special texture, but Greek yogurt might work in a pinch.
- → How many days will these bagels stay good?
- They'll be tasty for 2-3 days on your counter or up to a week if you keep them in the fridge.