Pin it
When tender, flavorful steak meets warm, buttery bread, you get something way beyond your typical lunch option. This sandwich combines juicy beef strips with sweet, slow-cooked onions, all hugged by melty havarti cheese inside a crunchy, golden-toasted baguette.
I stumbled onto using havarti cheese while throwing together food for friends one night - it melts beautifully and doesn't overpower the beef while adding this amazing smoothness.
Key Components and How to Pick Them
- Steak Choice: Go for ribeye if you want amazing marbling and softness
- Baguette: Look for one that's crispy outside and fluffy inside
- Havarti Cheese: Brings a smooth, melty layer that works with the meat
- Onions: Pick sweet varieties for the best caramelized flavor
- Butter: Don't skimp here - good butter makes the toast better
- Seasonings: Stick to salt and pepper to let the beef talk for itself
Finding Your Ideal Beef Cut
Getting the beef right makes all the difference in your sandwich. Ribeye gives you the most tender bite with awesome marbling throughout. If you're watching your spending but still want good tenderness, grab some top sirloin instead. Feeding a crowd? Skirt steak packs bold flavor and won't break the bank. NY strip sits nicely in the middle - reasonably tender and worth what you pay for it.
How to Nail the Process
- 1. Getting the Steak Right
- Take meat out early so it's not cold, Add plenty of salt and pepper, Give it time to rest after cooking
- 2. Making Perfect Onions
- Cut into same-size pieces, Cook them slowly on low heat, Scrape up the brown bits for extra taste
- 3. Putting It All Together
- Get the bread nice and golden, Stack everything in the right order, Slice diagonally for a nicer look
Pin it
Prep-Ahead Options
Getting stuff done early can make mealtime way easier. You can cook your steak and onions ahead of time and keep them ready to go. Just make sure to store everything separately so nothing gets soggy. For the best sandwich ever, wait until you're ready to eat before putting it all together - this keeps everything tasting its best.
Getting the Heat Just Right
Knowing your meat temps is super important for getting the steak exactly how you like it. If you want rare, shoot for 125°F inside. For medium-rare, you need about 135°F. Medium steak should hit 145°F. If you prefer medium-well, cook until it reaches 150°F. Having a meat thermometer handy really helps you nail this every time.
Keeping Everything Fresh
Storing things right keeps everything tasty for longer. Your cooked beef will stay good in the fridge for around three days. Those yummy caramelized onions can last even longer - up to five days refrigerated. But don't make the whole sandwich until you're ready to eat it, or it'll get mushy and lose its magic.
What to Serve Alongside
Round out your meal with sides that go great with these sandwiches. Hot, crunchy fries, a simple green salad, some tangy pickled veggies, creamy coleslaw, or even just some potato chips can make your meal feel complete and balanced.
Choosing the Right Bread
Your bread choice really matters for the final result. Look for a baguette that's got that perfect crackly outside and soft, airy inside. Don't skip toasting it right before you build your sandwich - this warm crunch against the soft filling makes every bite so much better.
Try Different Cheeses
Havarti works amazingly well, but you can switch things up with other cheeses too. Try provolone for something a bit sharper, Swiss for a nutty flavor, Gruyere when you want something rich, or white cheddar for a bit of tang. Our family always brushes the bread insides with garlic butter before toasting - it adds this crazy good flavor that totally transforms the sandwich.
Our household trick is adding garlic butter to the bread before it hits the toaster - it brings this amazing flavor depth you won't believe.
Pin it
After making this sandwich countless times, I've learned it's all about the little things - giving meat enough rest time, layering everything just so. The way that garlic-buttery bread gets crispy while the havarti gets all gooey against the warm beef creates this amazing mix of textures and flavors that'll blow you away. Doesn't matter if it's just a quick lunch or dinner for guests, it shows how sometimes the simplest combos make the most knockout meals.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which kind of steak works best here?
- Ribeye, strip steak, or sirloin are great. Pick one with good marbling and slice it thin across the grain.
- → Can I prep the herb butter earlier?
- Sure! It keeps for a week in the fridge. Pull it out and let it soften before adding it.
- → What cheese swaps are good for Havarti?
- Provolone, Swiss, or white cheddar are great melted and pair well with steak.
- → How can I get really sweet onions?
- Cook them low and slow over medium heat, stirring now and then. Sweet onions need time to develop their flavor.
- → Can I switch fresh dill for dried?
- Yep! Use 1 teaspoon dried dill instead, as it's more concentrated compared to fresh.