Pin it
This old-fashioned stovetop Rice Pudding turns basic pantry items into the ultimate comfort treat. Every bite gives you velvety, tender rice soaked with sweet vanilla and warm cinnamon notes. The rich brown sugar brings complexity while juicy raisins scatter pops of sweetness throughout. It's the dessert equivalent of a cozy blanket on a chilly night.
I tweaked this recipe over many cold nights, learning that taking your time and keeping an eye on things really matters. Even my grandma, who guards her kitchen secrets carefully, couldn't help but admit this version stands up to her family tradition.
Key Components
- Short-grain Rice: Packed with starch that makes everything creamy and smooth. Arborio is a great choice.
- Whole Milk: Gives that luxurious, smooth base. Don't skimp with low-fat options.
- Dark Brown Sugar: Brings those warm, molasses undertones you can't get from white sugar.
- Fresh Vanilla: Using real extract totally changes the end result.
- Large Egg: Helps everything thicken up while adding extra richness.
Pin it
Foolproof Method
- Getting Started Right:
- Pour milk and rice into a thick-bottomed pot. Warm it slowly, giving it an occasional stir. Look for small bubbles forming at the edges. Turn down the heat as soon as you spot bubbling.
- The Important Middle Part:
- Stir gently but often so nothing sticks. Notice how the rice slowly puffs up and softens. Keep the heat low and steady - don't rush it. The milk will slowly thicken as it cooks down.
- Bringing in Richness:
- Mix egg and sugar in another bowl until they're completely blended. Pour in some hot rice mixture bit by bit while mixing constantly. This gentle warming stops the egg from cooking too fast. Carefully pour everything back into the pot.
- Finishing Touches:
- Mix in vanilla and cinnamon as you're almost done cooking. Toss in raisins if you want them. Keep cooking until it's as thick as you like. Just remember it'll get thicker as it cools down.
After making this pudding countless times, I've noticed that using good milk makes a huge difference. Fresh whole milk from local farms gives a richness that turns this simple treat into something really special.
Heat Management
Getting the temperature just right is super important. Too hot and your milk burns or egg clumps up. Too cool and your rice stays crunchy. Using a pot with a thick bottom helps keep the heat nice and steady.
Better Next Day
This pudding actually tastes even better after sitting overnight as all the flavors mix together. I usually make it the day before we eat it, and put plastic wrap right on top of the pudding to keep it smooth.
After making batch after batch, I can say this rice pudding hits that sweet spot between easy and fancy. Whether you eat it warm when it's cold outside or chilled during hot weather, it always brings that feeling of comfort and happiness. The gentle sweetness and smooth texture make it a forever favorite that everyone from kids to grandparents will love.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What's special about short grain rice?
- Short grain rice gives off lots of starch, making your rice pudding extra creamy.
- → How does tempering eggs help?
- It keeps the eggs from scrambling when adding them to the hot rice mix.
- → Can this be prepared ahead of time?
- Absolutely! Serve it chilled or warm—it thickens as it cools.
- → Why's my pudding runny when it's hot?
- Don’t worry—it’ll firm up once it cools completely.
- → Can I substitute the milk?
- Whole milk makes it creamiest, but other types can work, though the texture might change.