Pin it
Mixing crunchy bagels with your favorite pizza fixings makes these homemade Pizza Bagels totally mouthwatering. They're done in about 15 minutes and give you all the pizza taste you love while using bagels instead of dough.
After trying many different versions, I found that balancing sauce and cheese just right while watching the heat makes them perfect. When my children started asking for these instead of calling for delivery, I knew we'd hit the jackpot.
Key Ingredients
- Plain Bagels: Work as the ideal foundation
- Tomato Passata: Makes the tastiest base layer
- Grated Mozzarella: Gives better melt than the fresh kind
Step-by-Step Guide
- Making Your Sauce (3 minutes):
- Combine passata in container. Drop in garlic granules. Mix dried oregano throughout. Add salt and pepper as needed. Set aside for later use.
- Putting It Together (5 minutes):
- Cut bagels across the middle. Add sauce in thin layer. Don't make them soggy. Pile cheese on top. Add extra toppings you want.
- Cooking Options (time depends on method):
- Oven: 8-10 minutes at 400°F. Air Fryer: 5-7 minutes at 375°F. Grill: 3-5 minutes with high heat.
Pin it
Cooking Techniques and Heat Tips
Different cooking ways need different attention. In your oven, the even warmth helps cheese melt smoothly while making the bagel edges nice and crisp. Air fryers make them extra crunchy but you'll need to check often so they don't burn. Under the broiler, the strong heat from above browns them beautifully but you can't walk away for a second.
Pin it
Tasty Topping Ideas
- Pepperoni with loads of cheese
- Sweet pineapple with ham chunks
- Sliced mushrooms and black olives
- Tangy BBQ chicken with sliced onion
Prep Ahead Ideas
They're best fresh but you can get ready beforehand:
- Prepare sauce and keep it in the fridge
- Shred cheese the day before
- Cut bagels ahead of time
- Chop all your toppings
Keeping Leftovers Fresh
If you need to save some for later:
- Let them cool down completely
- Store them in containers that seal
- Warm them up the same way you cooked them
- Try not to use the microwave if you can help it
These Pizza Bagels mix two wonderful things together - quick and easy bagels with all those yummy pizza flavors. They're perfect when kids are starving or when you want a fast meal that still tastes great. The mix of crunchy bagel base, gooey melted cheese, and whatever toppings you love makes something that's fun to put together and awesome to eat.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What's the easiest way to cook them?
- Air fryer is the fastest, oven handles more at once, and the grill gives great browning.
- → Can I prep these early?
- Totally! Keep them in the fridge for up to 3 days. They even taste great cold!
- → Are there specific bagels to use?
- You can use any plain bagels, though traditional or whole wheat work best.
- → Is freezing an option?
- You can try, but they’re much better fresh since bagels can lose texture when frozen.
- → What are good topping ideas?
- Go wild! Use anything you love—meats, veggies, cheeses, or even extra sauce.