Pin it
Grandma's kitchen always springs to mind when I think about sugar cookies. I love feeling the silky dough as I flatten it on my marble surface. After lots of kitchen experiments and adjusting formulas at home, I've come up with these incredibly soft, thick sugar cookies that won't lose their shape. Believe me, you'll never want store-bought ones again once you've got this down pat.
Why These Cookies Stand Out
These sugar cookies can do so many things. They've got this awesome combo of pillowy middles and slightly crunchy edges. Their flat tops work perfectly when I'm playing with royal icing designs. My children can't help grabbing a few plain ones right off the rack because they taste fantastic even without any fancy toppings. And guess what? When you store them right, they'll stay yummy in your cookie container for nearly a week.
Pin it
Your Ingredient List
- Butter: Get it out early so it softens. I stick with unsalted to manage the salt level myself.
- Sugar: Just plain granulated sugar does the trick.
- Egg: You'll only need one large egg, straight from the fridge.
- Vanilla Extract: Don't skimp here, go for pure vanilla. I sometimes add a drop of almond extract too.
- Flour: Nothing fancy, all-purpose flour works great.
- Baking Powder: Just a bit creates that wonderful soft texture.
- Salt: A little dash enhances all the flavors.
Baking Steps
- Create Your Base
- Whip softened butter with sugar until it gets airy and pale. Add your egg and vanilla. In a separate container mix your dry stuff then gradually combine everything until your dough forms.
- Prep For Cooling
- Cut the dough into two parts. Flatten each between parchment sheets until it matches your pinky's thickness. Stick them in the fridge for at least 60 minutes or leave overnight if you're busy.
- Oven Action
- Warm your oven to 350°F. Cut your shapes and put them on lined trays. Cook for around 12 minutes until the edges turn slightly golden. Let them cool fully before adding any decorations.
- Dress Them Up
- Pick whatever frosting you enjoy. Royal icing is great for detailed work. Simple glaze works if you're just starting out. Buttercream tastes wonderful but won't harden completely.
Smart Cookie Tricks
I've found that flattening the dough before cooling makes everything easier later on. My silicone mats are perfect for this job. They go right from countertop to refrigerator without any trouble. Always work with smaller dough portions while keeping the rest cool. I can't say enough good things about my adjustable rolling pin for getting cookies the same thickness every time.
Decoration Ideas
After decorating tons of cookies in my kitchen, I only use gel food colors now. They create stunning shades without thinning your icing. I always reach for my Wilton #4 tip when outlining and filling. If I'm rushed, squeeze bottles come in handy instead. Nothing beats a sprinkle of shimmery edible dust or cute little decorations for making cookies look festive.
Storage Solutions
These treats stay good in my cookie container for about seven days. When planning ahead, I often freeze plain cookies or extra dough. They're totally fine in the freezer for three months. Just let them warm up on the counter before adding icing. And don't worry if you get busy, your dough will wait in the fridge for a couple days no problem.
Pin it
Personal Touches
I sometimes throw in some orange peel for a fruity kick. Other times adding a bit of cinnamon gives them a warm, cozy feel. My little girl loves helping pick different shapes for holidays. We go with hearts when Valentine's Day comes around and stars for Christmas time. You can go wild with different colors and decorations.
Essential Baking Tools
My mixer does all the heavy lifting when making cookies. Good quality baking trays and silicone mats stop anything from sticking. Cookie cutters with sharp edges create clean lines. For decorating stuff, I always have gel colors, piping bags and different tips ready to go. An adjustable rolling pin helps with consistent thickness and those little coupler rings make swapping decorating tips super simple.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s the purpose of chilling the dough?
- Cold dough doesn’t spread much while baking, keeping cookie shapes neat. It also makes rolling and cutting simpler.
- → Can you freeze these cookies?
- Absolutely! Both plain or decorated cookies stay good in the freezer for 3 months. The raw dough works too for later use.
- → Why does butter’s temperature matter?
- Butter that’s cool but soft keeps the dough manageable. Over-soft butter makes things sticky and the cookies lose texture.
- → How thick should I roll out the dough?
- Stick to 1/4-inch thickness. It’s just right to balance crispy edges with a soft center while baking evenly.
- → How long do they stay fresh?
- Plain or frosted, they stay soft for 5 days at room temp. Refrigerate for up to 10 days or freeze for 3 months.